I just caught up on my reading & All Star Batman & Robin the Boy Wonder is way out of hand. First, they're up to #7 and no Robin yet. Second, they repeat "Goddamn Batman" constantly which wasn't funny to begin with & is just being done cause fans complained about it. Third, Bats bags Black Canary with masks on, way out of character. Fourth, even more out of character is Bats becoming worse than the Punisher in treatment of criminals.
I thought Miller knew Batman. I could understand a wacked out Bats in Dark Knight because that was in the "future" in a totally violence, out of control world. He seemed to get him right in Year One. But he's lost it in DK2 & All Star.