Thanks to: me, The Pumpkinhead, steven616, sinestro24, Uninvited Guest, fan4, and Jared for participating.

7 votes each:
1) Thor
2) The Wolverine
3) The Thing
4) The Hulk
5) Spider-man
6) Iron Man
7) Captain America (Steve Rogers)

6 votes each:
8) The She-Hulk
9) The Human Torch (Johny Storm)
10) The Ghost Rider
11) Doctor Strange
12) Daredevil

5 votes each:
13) The Sub-mariner
14) The Silver Surfer
15) Storm
16) Nick Fury

4 votes each:
17) The Invisible Woman
18) The Black Panther
19) Luke Cage

3 votes each:
20) Mister Fantastic

2 votes each (four tie for 25th):
21) The Black Widow
22) Ms. Marvel
23) Iron Fist
24) Hercules
25) Hawkeye
25) Elektra
25) Captain Britain
25) Captain America (Bucky Barnes)