Avengers >> View Post
Post By
Nick

In Reply To
Brand Echh

Subj: Re: Pro-Reg defense.
Posted: Sat May 12, 2007 at 03:53:18 am EDT
Reply Subj: Pro-Reg defense.
Posted: Sat May 12, 2007 at 02:30:02 am EDT

Previous Post

> I have been reading these post on the cival war for quite a while. And though you guys make many valid points i must say. and understand this its just my openion. The fact that most of you find what iron-man and shield are doing is ok scares the heck out of me. cap is dead and no one seems to care. but for a second lets under stand what that means, the liveing symbole of what america truely means,is the first person to side aginst this. now i know what some of you will say he surenderd. but understand he did that only because innocent people were getting hurt and they seemed to agree with stark.However as luke cage commented slavery was once a law, but that did not make it right. Just because something seems to be the right way to go doesent mean it is.And by the way is anyone payeing attention to the marvel universe now? because i am haveing trouble reconizeing these people. I appears we dont need villians anymore, The heroes are fillng that role just fine. \:\-\(

See, that's the thing. I don't disagree with you. Tony has been every bit the villain the past few years (of course, he always stradled that edge without anyone noticing...) - however, I do agree with registration in concept and (so far) in practice. Anyone with potentially lethal weapons (even their own hands) should be trained and lisenced to use them properly and be officially accountable for any personal or property damage that results from the possession of said damage. This can only happen with registration. Additionally, some people are just too powerful to give a lisence to fly and let loose, so I also agree with the draft to an extent, although I feel it's been over emphasized somewhat.

To sum: I disagree with Tony's methods, but I agree with the result.


> > I have been reading these post on the cival war for quite a while. And though you guys make many valid points i must say. and understand this its just my openion. The fact that most of you find what iron-man and shield are doing is ok scares the heck out of me. cap is dead and no one seems to care. but for a second lets under stand what that means, the liveing symbole of what america truely means,is the first person to side aginst this. now i know what some of you will say he surenderd. but understand he did that only because innocent people were getting hurt and they seemed to agree with stark.However as luke cage commented slavery was once a law, but that did not make it right. Just because something seems to be the right way to go doesent mean it is.And by the way is anyone payeing attention to the marvel universe now? because i am haveing trouble reconizeing these people. I appears we dont need villians anymore, The heroes are fillng that role just fine. \:\-\(
>
> See, that's the thing. I don't disagree with you. Tony has been every bit the villain the past few years (of course, he always stradled that edge without anyone noticing...) - however, I do agree with registration in concept and (so far) in practice. Anyone with potentially lethal weapons (even their own hands) should be trained and lisenced to use them properly and be officially accountable for any personal or property damage that results from the possession of said damage. This can only happen with registration. Additionally, some people are just too powerful to give a lisence to fly and let loose, so I also agree with the draft to an extent, although I feel it's been over emphasized somewhat.
>
> To sum: I disagree with Tony's methods, but I agree with the result.
>

See I dont think its a bad thing to have a record of what each hero can do and who they are. However Its another to force someone to serve the government because their special. You see the government can not lisence people to live. Its one thing if you look at heroes like ironman and black widow who choose to be a hero. Yes lisense those who choose. However if the life of tights is not for you then you should not have to fight for the gov. I mean here are someperfect examples Cloud 9 just wants to fly she shouldnt be a soldier. Jessica Jones wants to live her life and raise her child in peace not fight crime she does not need to register. The runaways shouldnt have to register these are kids who only step in to help people when no one else is around to help civilians they want to live their lives and disappearthey do not need to register. Its one thing to keep track of anyone who wants to put on tights and play hero, and i agree young heroes should be trained. However heroes should not work soely for the government that just turns them into weapons for the president to deply on a whim which is wrong. Also every single file on a mutant should be erased because force registering ALL mutants is racisim plain and simple no if ands or buts about it. I am so happy to see the new NEW Warriors showing the youthful rebelion in the face of the iron menace.