Batman >> View Post
Post By
Dr.Dom

In Reply To
MattS80

Subj: You're right in my opinion....though I still liked it...
Posted: Wed Feb 14, 2007 at 07:19:59 pm EST
Reply Subj: Batman: Year One is NOT The Best Batman Story.
Posted: Wed Feb 14, 2007 at 03:54:17 pm EST

Previous Post

Does anyone agree with me that Batman: Year One is a little bit overrated. I do think it's pretty good, and I really like the (Jim) Gordon parts, but I don't really see why people hold this storyline as the best or second best Batman story. It did have really good art. Maybe I'll re-read it again, but I think the Long Halloween was better.

> Does anyone agree with me that Batman: Year One is a little bit overrated. I do think it's pretty good, and I really like the (Jim) Gordon parts, but I don't really see why people hold this storyline as the best or second best Batman story. It did have really good art. Maybe I'll re-read it again, but I think the Long Halloween was better.


I agree that the Long Halloween was better, as was The Dark Knight Returns.

Both very well written and great art....

I agree that it is a bit over-rated...