Batman >> View Post
Post By
Gernot

In Reply To
Blue Jay

Subj: Re: The joker is here!
Posted: Mon Dec 03, 2007 at 05:33:47 pm EST (Viewed 1 times)
Reply Subj: Re: The joker is here!
Posted: Sat Dec 01, 2007 at 06:22:30 pm EST (Viewed 1 times)

Previous Post

> But can that work with a character like the Joker?

If done right, then yes. Nolan just has to find the right balance.

> Out of curiosity, by whom? I found him to be overblown, lacking in anything like genuine menace and played more like a panto villain by Anthony Hopkins.

Well, by people the world over, but the main group that brought attention to this are the American Film Institute that voted for the one hundred best heroes and villains in movie history. AFI voted for him as the number one movie villain of all time.

The Silence of the Lambs made Hannibal Lecter recognized as the best villain in movie history the world over.

The menace of Dr. Lecter is that you cannot hide anything from him and he can bring out your deepest darkest fears. Think about meeting this guy that eats people he does not like but instead of attacking you he sits there just staring into your eyes telling you your biggest darkest secrets, taking away all your mental defense mechanisums, and then slowly but surely getting into your head as you watch him paint a masterpiece. If you are lucky you might not go insane, you might instead become his puppoet, or at worst become his meal.

>As the Joker in this movie seems to have not that much in common with the comics, one wonders why.

Well, we will have to wait and see for that to be sure, but so far I think he does have much in common with his comic book counterpart.

>And the rest of the Batman mythos isn't?

Depends on which comics of the Batman mythos you read. I try to read the most realistic ones only.


> > But can that work with a character like the Joker?
>
> If done right, then yes. Nolan just has to find the right balance.
>
> > Out of curiosity, by whom? I found him to be overblown, lacking in anything like genuine menace and played more like a panto villain by Anthony Hopkins.
>
> Well, by people the world over, but the main group that brought attention to this are the American Film Institute that voted for the one hundred best heroes and villains in movie history. AFI voted for him as the number one movie villain of all time.
>
> The Silence of the Lambs made Hannibal Lecter recognized as the best villain in movie history the world over.
>
> The menace of Dr. Lecter is that you cannot hide anything from him and he can bring out your deepest darkest fears. Think about meeting this guy that eats people he does not like but instead of attacking you he sits there just staring into your eyes telling you your biggest darkest secrets, taking away all your mental defense mechanisums, and then slowly but surely getting into your head as you watch him paint a masterpiece. If you are lucky you might not go insane, you might instead become his puppoet, or at worst become his meal.
>
> >As the Joker in this movie seems to have not that much in common with the comics, one wonders why.
>
> Well, we will have to wait and see for that to be sure, but so far I think he does have much in common with his comic book counterpart.
>
> >And the rest of the Batman mythos isn't?
>
> Depends on which comics of the Batman mythos you read. I try to read the most realistic ones only.
>

Heh. I'll bet you don't read very much! \:D

Gernot...

*The Justice League Of America Board

*The Cartoon Board

My MySpace

My YouTube Channel

My Yahoo Clubs!

Superman, Man Of Tomorrow

To Be Continued

Kartoon Klub