Marvel Universe >> View Post
·
Post By
Paul

In Reply To
Tiger Shark

Subj: Re: I Know Where You're Coming From, Since We've Discussed This Many Times
Posted: Wed Sep 05, 2007 at 12:52:31 am EDT
Reply Subj: I Know Where You're Coming From, Since We've Discussed This Many Times
Posted: Tue Sep 04, 2007 at 02:34:01 pm EDT (Viewed 1 times)

Previous Post

Many of us are completely disenchanted with the Rhino, the Green Goblin/Norman Osborn, Mr. Hyde, the Juggernaut, the Wrecking Crew, Venom, Carnage, Sabertooth, Magneto, and others due to constant overuse. I'm one of them.

It's not that I don't like these characters, but when we see them trotted out month in and month out, they lose all their appeal, especially, when has been the case under JQ, they're not used very creatively (see, for example, Austin's and Bendis' use of the Wrecking Crew/Wrecker, and the WC didn't do much that was interesting in the recent Omega Flight either).

To some of us, using the same characters endlessly seems both lazy and unimaginative.

I'd much rather see a writer take a lesser or little used character like Karnilla, Black Wing, the Brute, Maelstrom, Umar, the Faceless One, Ymir, Centurion, Halflife, the Man-Bull, Mesmero, the Hang Man, Vermin, the Vanisher, the Griffin, Quicksand, the Petrified Man, the Pirahna, the Enchantress, the original Jester, Llyra, Zaladane, the Tatterdamalion, the Unicorn, ZZAAAXXX, the Mongoose, Mr. Kline, Dragonfly, etc. and really do something with them--that is, set them front and center stage in an arc, as they deserve to be.

Marvel has a backlog of literally hundreds of such 'evil' characters, some who simply never found a creative advocate as, say, Sabertooth did.

A secondary part of this is that all too often, the villains/criminals/antagonists are just trotted out for a few panels with little if any characterization, are treated like objects of humor by obth writer and heroes, and are then thumped back into whatever degree of limbo or oblivion they currently hale from.

Personally, I have little interest in buying a book in which the Man-pae stands around cooking breakfast while wearing a bathrobe over his costume---Marvel has really sacrificed a lot for a few very cheap shots at humor.

But it's easier to come up with a silly, unfunny joke to justify an entire 22-pages than write a full-bodied, full-blooded story like we used to get.

While I'm not particularly interested in the "controversy" about the Rhino, and I'm *really* not interested in contributing to another iteration of the old "comics were more fun when I started reading them than they are now" tale, your list of villains you want to see revived is intruiging. Some of the characters on the list (the Hang Man, Mongoose, Quicksand, Man-Bull, Vermin, the Unicorn) all have decent gimics, cool designs (or at least the potential for good redesigns), and interesting power sets. I would totally be in favor of, say, Spider-Man having to stop the Man-Bull instead on Mr. Hyde from robbing a bank if a given story called for it. And the team of Mongoose and Quicksand could be substituted for the Wrecking Crew in a number of instances. So I'm totally with you there. Also, for all we know, the various Asgardian villains you mention may well come back now that there's a reqular Thor book again, so there's that. On the other hand, not every villian from Marvel's past is exactly ripe for revival, in my oppinion. Mr. Klein, for example, is probably best left to the dustbin of early 70s comics. His origin is too complicated and inconsistent, and even if a writer wanted to clear all that up, why bother for a relatively generic robot assassin/mastermind from another dimension/time/whatever it was (see, overly convoluted origin). I agree with your overall argument, but only insofar as it encourages the reintroduction of needlessly underused but otherwise sound characters in place of overexposed ones.


> Many of us are completely disenchanted with the Rhino, the Green Goblin/Norman Osborn, Mr. Hyde, the Juggernaut, the Wrecking Crew, Venom, Carnage, Sabertooth, Magneto, and others due to constant overuse. I'm one of them.
>
> It's not that I don't like these characters, but when we see them trotted out month in and month out, they lose all their appeal, especially, when has been the case under JQ, they're not used very creatively (see, for example, Austin's and Bendis' use of the Wrecking Crew/Wrecker, and the WC didn't do much that was interesting in the recent Omega Flight either).
>
> To some of us, using the same characters endlessly seems both lazy and unimaginative.
>
> I'd much rather see a writer take a lesser or little used character like Karnilla, Black Wing, the Brute, Maelstrom, Umar, the Faceless One, Ymir, Centurion, Halflife, the Man-Bull, Mesmero, the Hang Man, Vermin, the Vanisher, the Griffin, Quicksand, the Petrified Man, the Pirahna, the Enchantress, the original Jester, Llyra, Zaladane, the Tatterdamalion, the Unicorn, ZZAAAXXX, the Mongoose, Mr. Kline, Dragonfly, etc. and really do something with them--that is, set them front and center stage in an arc, as they deserve to be.
>
> Marvel has a backlog of literally hundreds of such 'evil' characters, some who simply never found a creative advocate as, say, Sabertooth did.
>
> A secondary part of this is that all too often, the villains/criminals/antagonists are just trotted out for a few panels with little if any characterization, are treated like objects of humor by obth writer and heroes, and are then thumped back into whatever degree of limbo or oblivion they currently hale from.
>
> Personally, I have little interest in buying a book in which the Man-pae stands around cooking breakfast while wearing a bathrobe over his costume---Marvel has really sacrificed a lot for a few very cheap shots at humor.
>
> But it's easier to come up with a silly, unfunny joke to justify an entire 22-pages than write a full-bodied, full-blooded story like we used to get.


Posted with Microsoft Internet Explorer 6 on Windows XP
Alvaro's Comicboards powered by On Topic™ © 2003-2022 Powermad Software
All the content of these boards Copyright © 1996-2022 by Comicboards/TVShowboards. Software Copyright © 2003-2022 Powermad Software