Marvel Universe >> View Post
Post By
Merzah the Mystic

In Reply To
Omar Karindu

Member Since: Sat May 17, 2008
Posts: 4,242
Subj: Re: Villains subjected to LEGAL execution in the Marvel Universe, New Universe, and What If? worlds
Posted: Sun Jul 05, 2009 at 02:41:06 pm CDT (Viewed 94 times)
Reply Subj: Villains subjected to LEGAL execution in the Marvel Universe, New Universe, and What If? worlds
Posted: Thu Jul 02, 2009 at 11:06:02 am CDT (Viewed 323 times)

Previous Post

I was just thinking about how rare it is to see villains tried and executed for their crimes, even now that every other villain is a mass murderer. At best, you get mentions that they're sentenced to capital punishment or stories where, for once, they're innocent of the crime and the hero must prevent a miscarriage of justice.

So I figured I'd get the ball rolling on those rare cases in which bad guys actually go through some sort of legal process and are executed. These executions may not stick, mind you, but the state apparently tries once in awhile.

Bear in mind that I'm looking for legal executions specifically; legal deaths like the Crime-Master being shot by the police in a standoff or utterly illegitimate processes like HYDRA's show trials for failed operatives and the likes of Baron Strucker or the Neverland concentration camp really don't count in terms of what I'm asking about. I'd also like to avoid real people who appeared as villains in comics, though: Nazis and Mussolini and so forth shouldn't count here.

A popular variant is to make the execution the origin, rather than the finish, of a supervillain. Minor Midnight Sons enemy Short Circuit, for instance was empowered by the electric chair, and at least one of the Externals only discovered his immortality after a hanging. I'm not sure I'd count either one, since I'm more interested in stories that use legal execution as the villain's comeuppance. The dismantling of sentient robots and the like by government strikes me as a gray area, but as long as it's the result of some kind of real legal process and not a "heat of battle" situation, I figure they're close enough. Alas, the Vision's the only example I can think of here, and he's not really a villain getting comeuppance at the end of a story when it happens to him.

At Marvel, I honestly can't think of any! DC had a few I know of, mostly in the 1940s, but Marvel...not so much.

ive always imagined hat the MU worked on a different legal system than our universe. for example, heroes are rarely if ever called to the witness stand against villains even if the heroes might be the most prominent witness to the villains crimes. Also, there seems to be some slight right to privacy in not unmasking captured heroes, even if it is unofficial, something wed never even consider in the real world.

id always assumed that the death penalty is not used in the united states of the MU. or at least so rarely used that its basically forbidden (like in the real world EU).

I always thoght there were some good stories lurking in dealing with the death penalty. but i think for several reasons writers avoid it like the plague. first off, its a controversial subject. writers get nervous for their jobs anytime they get too close to something that could cause the wrong kind of controversy. which is why we get countries like Madripoor, Halwan, Costa Verde and Madeupistan. then, well, villains always come back from the dead anyway, so why bother.

It would be interesting to judge the villain most likely to be executed if captured in the real world. (Id vote for the red skull. He seems most likely to be tried for war crimes)