Ha! I needed a good laugh! no, I assume you are referring to that What If special, that was almost as poorly done as civil war itself,
It seems to me that that writer thought SHRA was a good idea, and agreed with Iron man, where as the majority of fans ( it seems to me ) agreed with fighting against it and captain america.
Seems to me like the message of that What If was that Captain America and Iron Man were both too extreme in the position they took, everything worked out in the universe where they were able to put aside their fighting and find a common ground. And I don't think it was that poorly done, it's not at all unreasonable to think that if Tony Stark didn't take control of implementing the SHRA, someone much worse would have.