Eh. I never really cared for him or Tobey MaGuire. IMO Grant Gustin would be a perfect Peter Parker, it's almost a shame he was cast as the Flash because he is too young and looks nothing like Barry Allen but still somehow does a good job in the role but his association with Barry would probably keep him from consideration for Spider-Man.
I keep telling my wife the one actor who could probably pull off Peter/Spidey is Nicholas Hoult. Look at him in the glasses in the X-men movies... that's Peter at the beginning, dead on. Take those specs off and you have current Peter. I think he's got the right stuff to get all of Peter's strengths, humor, quirks, faults, and other personalty traits right. The added plus is that he doesn't have an annoying voice. I liked Tobey better as Spidey, but never felt either he nor Garfield has the voice to go under the mask.