Amazing Spider-Man Message Board >> View Post
Post By

Member Since: Sat Oct 08, 2016
In Reply To

Member Since: Fri Nov 26, 2021
Subj: Re: History of a Rumor: Did Steve Ditko Really Have Issues with Spider-Man graduating High School?
Posted: Thu Jan 13, 2022 at 11:41:53 am EST (Viewed 100 times)
Reply Subj: Re: History of a Rumor: Did Steve Ditko Really Have Issues with Spider-Man graduating High School?
Posted: Thu Jan 13, 2022 at 09:00:48 am EST (Viewed 103 times)

Previous Post

    I am genuinely looking forward to a Ditko biography after reading your site. I read a bit more today about the high school question on your page. It seems a lot of myth built up around Ditko, and we have to openly ask whether whole Objectivism took over his life theory was wrong too.

Oh, Ditko was an objectivist and it did take over his life. That much is clear. The question for me has always been about "when".

Like when did Ditko become a serious Ayn Rand fan, a serious Ayn Rand devotee, and what was the process between his reading of Rand and his "radicalization"? Because the obvious fact is that Steve Ditko was born in 1927. Ayn Rand's major success and the work that most fully embodied her "ideas" and popularized Objectivism was Atlas Shrugged which came out in 1957. By which time Ditko was thirty and already working at Atlas comics with Stan Lee on several anthology stuff. So obviously, in terms of Ditko's life, Rand was a recent influence, not a childhood influence. He wasn't raised a Randian. At some point he remade and reinvented himself into a Randian. So there's a Ditko before-Rand and a Ditko after-Rand and so far no serious study on Ditko has really grasped that. Blake Bell's Strange and Stranger does that somewhat but even it falls into simplifications.

The major problem with Ditko and Rand is that too much is centered on Spider-Man, when at the same time he worked on Spider-Man he was working on Doctor Strange. Yet nobody looks at Doctor Strange and does Objectivist readings of that comic, even if that was actually a title Ditko had far more of a say over, given that it was an idea generated by himself whereas Spider-Man was a failed Simon/Kirby project he bailed out. Like during the 1960s, Doctor Strange was popular among counter-culture and hippies so it's not like Ditko was seen as a Randian by readers of Marvel during his time there. Right after Ditko left Marvel, he worked on horror comics for Warren under Archie Goodwin, and those black-and-white horror comics are considered among his best work, and it was in 1967 that he published Mr. A and became publicly known as an objectivist.

Blake Bell's biography mentions that Stan Lee was the one who recommended Ditko to read Ayn Rand's books. Lee was a fan and admirer of Rand, and Riesman's biography confirms that Lee censored a Jack Kirby comic in Fantastic Four that would have spoofed Rand. So that does mean that Stan Lee was the one who dropped Ditko into the vat of acid, so to speak. And to the extent there's objectivism in Spider-Man it's not entirely from Ditko.

Psychologically this stuff is fascinating but also deeply toxic. Lee could read Rand and like stuff and take ideas there, and then move on to some new fad author whereas Ditko committed himself to Rand for the rest of his life. There's something tragic to that, like Ditko both relied on Lee for intellectual ideas and yet sought to better Lee by out-Randing him, and that ended up ruining his career basically.

Totally agree about Rand. It doesn't do to have a guru. Some of the most life affirming things I've ever read have been by Rand. Some of Rand's work really helps me in working with drug and alcohol clients seeking clarity and self respect. On the other hand some of Rand's statements and work such as Atlas Shrugged - is full of leave them to die mentality and kills any actual veneration for the author. It's enough to say her work can be thought provoking.

I had NO idea Stan Lee liked some of Rand's work.

I will be fascinated to one day find out why Ditko became a recluse of sorts. I suspect the Rand obsession might have been the early manic part of a prelude to breakdown of some sort, but I'm guessing.

Posted with Google Chrome 97.0.4692.71 on Windows 10
Alvaro's Comicboards powered by On Topic™ © 2003-2022 Powermad Software
All the content of these boards Copyright © 1996-2022 by Comicboards/TVShowboards. Software Copyright © 2003-2022 Powermad Software