The Superman Family Message Board >> View Post
·
Post By
Blue Beetle

In Reply To
Eno Orazzib

Subj: Re: Bring Back Supergirl
Posted: Sat Nov 10, 2007 at 09:27:28 pm EST
Reply Subj: Bring Back Supergirl
Posted: Sat Nov 10, 2007 at 07:49:59 pm EST

Previous Post

Good-bye

As one of those absolutely loved the Byrne-era, it may surprise a few people that were actually a couple of things that I thought he threw the baby out with the bathwater. One of them was Kara Zor-El.

And, over the years DC did try to bring in some kind of Supergirl like Matrix from the Pocket Universe, the often-overlooked Power Girl, and the Linda Danvers/Matrix hybrid, none of them truly matched up to Kara Zor-El. Until Jeph Loeb came up with his Girl From Krypton arc.

I am one of Loeb's biggest critics. I am not a fan of his story-telling, but I do think he has some of the best ideas in the comic biz. And his first issue of the Girl from Krypton had me at the edge of my seat. After that, it seemed as if he and others have dropped the ball on Kara.

In her first story arc, the readers totally lose out on any kind of insight to this character as her first several weeks/months(I forget which) is spent off-panel and on Paradise Island with a bunch of Amazons (one of my own personal fantasies as well). We spend months wondering if this was the real deal or a Darkseid plot.

When do find out it is the real girl of steel, we are whisked to her own book where we discover she has an attitude and love of skimpy outfits that make ankle look skinny. We are treated with issue after issue of guest starring super heroes for her whale on. She encounters Luthor way too early with no sense of build up. And she seems pretty much on her own for an extremely tall 16-year old alien.

Superman is so excited to have some family still alive that he pretty much ignores her except for some cameos here and there. We had more of a sense of brotherly love in those quaint 8-page stories of the silver age. She's shacking up with Boomerbutt's son? There's no supporting cast. No subplots, except for Zor-El wanting his nephew dead. (I think it's funny that so writers have a problem with a teenage Clark Kent playing football, but have no problem with kryptonain fraternicide?)

It seems that nowadays comic creative staff believes that give women attitudes makes them modern and politically correct, but we already have a female kryptonian with attitude, it is the underused Power Girl. (and maybe Karsta Wor-Ul can be added to this as well).

Why can't we have the sweet Supergirl of the past? Why can't we have the Danvers? Why can't we have her attending school in Midvale? Why can't we have Dick Malverne?

Over in the Superman titles, we have elements of both the Silver Age (Legion of Super-Heroes for example) and the Christopher Reeve movies (Zod, Ursa, Non, Ice Palace of Solitude, etc) returning. Why can't we have those return to Supergirl as well? While the Supergirl movie wasn't the blockbuster that Superman movies were, Helen Slater was great as this somewhat naive, but courageous alien girl try to fight badguys and save her home.

The creative team I belive are missing something by ignoring these elements told in a modern 21st-century view of storytelling of a young, powerful 16-year old alien comparing and contrasting her home and family now and those of Argo City/Krypton. Whereas Superman grew up here and learned of the wonders of Krypton, we now Kara who would look at from the opposite direction. And it seems as if Superman and Supergirl are avoiding each other unless there is some dire problem where they have to fight along side each other.

Am I the only one who thinks this way, and believed they are missing some great story opportunities.

Hello!
Eno Orazzib

>
> Good-bye

Hello.


> As one of those absolutely loved the Byrne-era, it may surprise a few people that were actually a couple of things that I thought he threw the baby out with the bathwater. One of them was Kara Zor-El.


I disliked the Byrne era. It made no sense to me because Superman was powered down but the other heroes weren't, which left me thinking that Superman was no longer the most powerful hero, and that bugged me. If all the heroes had been powered down, I might have had a different reaction.


> And, over the years DC did try to bring in some kind of Supergirl like Matrix from the Pocket Universe, the often-overlooked Power Girl, and the Linda Danvers/Matrix hybrid, none of them truly matched up to Kara Zor-El. Until Jeph Loeb came up with his Girl From Krypton arc.


The incarnations you mention have their fans. I like Power Girl but I never liked the Matrix character, though I know many did.


> I am one of Loeb's biggest critics. I am not a fan of his story-telling, but I do think he has some of the best ideas in the comic biz.


I'm not a fan of Loeb at all.


> And his first issue of the Girl from Krypton had me at the edge of my seat. After that, it seemed as if he and others have dropped the ball on Kara.


I too was on the edge of my seat, but not because of Loeb. Any writer who was telling this particular story would have had me riveted. I only cared about one thing: Was this girl Kryptonian?


> In her first story arc, the readers totally lose out on any kind of insight to this character as her first several weeks/months(I forget which) is spent off-panel and on Paradise Island with a bunch of Amazons (one of my own personal fantasies as well). We spend months wondering if this was the real deal or a Darkseid plot.


Torturing us with a mystery of this sort is traditional comic book technique so I can't fault anyone in this instance.


> When do find out it is the real girl of steel, we are whisked to her own book where we discover she has an attitude and love of skimpy outfits that make ankle look skinny. We are treated with issue after issue of guest starring super heroes for her whale on. She encounters Luthor way too early with no sense of build up. And she seems pretty much on her own for an extremely tall 16-year old alien.


I didn't buy her solo comic for a long time. I recently have begun ordering it, concurrent with the beginning of the new writer's tenure, because the new writer used to be on Batgirl and that was a really good comic.


> Superman is so excited to have some family still alive that he pretty much ignores her except for some cameos here and there. We had more of a sense of brotherly love in those quaint 8-page stories of the silver age.


This is typical of DC in recent years. Supposedly Superman had a soft spot for Conner yet he rarely visited.


> It seems that nowadays comic creative staff believes that give women attitudes makes them modern and politically correct, but we already have a female kryptonian with attitude, it is the underused Power Girl. (and maybe Karsta Wor-Ul can be added to this as well).


The original Supergirl was classic. I would love to have her back. But at least the one we have is Kryptonian, is Superman's cousin, arrived on Earth as a teen-ager, is blonde, and wears the red, yellow, and blue. I'm thankful we have that much.


> Why can't we have the sweet Supergirl of the past? Why can't we have the Danvers? Why can't we have her attending school in Midvale? Why can't we have Dick Malverne?


I guess because none of that sold comic books in sufficient numbers.

Also, to a certain extent the "sweet Supergirl of the past" is unlikely to exist in a realistic storytelling milieu. Teen-agers have attitudes. This is normal. Imagine a teen-ager with invincible super powers and thus little to fear from any person short of Darkseid. Surely there would be discipline problems. At least the modern Supergirl is choosing to help the world with her powers. Many, many, many teen-agers, if given such awesome super powers, would use them for purely selfish ends.


> ...Whereas Superman grew up here and learned of the wonders of Krypton, we now Kara who would look at from the opposite direction.


Interesting contrast worth exploring, I agree.


>
> Hello!


Good-bye!



Posted with Microsoft Internet Explorer 6 on Windows XP
Alvaro's Comicboards powered by On Topic™ © 2003-2022 Powermad Software
All the content of these boards Copyright © 1996-2022 by Comicboards/TVShowboards. Software Copyright © 2003-2022 Powermad Software